Wednesday, January 02, 2008

Book Review #45 - March


I rarely buy books. This is true for several reasons, but if I'm ever missing, you'd have a much better chance at finding me by looking in library rather than a bookstore.

However, last month, for Blogger Bookclub, we had a book exchange and I found myself in a bookstore perusing the shelves. First of all, I could quickly change my borrowing ways if I were forced to walk through a bookstore every day. I loved it! So many rectangular shapes that wanted to be slid off shelves and bent open. I found myself off task and reading the jackets of many a book.

Which is precisely how I found this gem. Booksellers tend to pimp their bestsellers by displaying their front covers as opposed to the binding, making it easier to catch the buyer's eye. Right at my eye level was the book Year of Wonders by Geraldine Brooks. I surmised that it was about the plague and while that wasn't the type of story I was looking for, placed right next to it was Brooks's second, and equally acclaimed book: March, a 2006 Pulitzer Prize winner.

It is the story of Peter March, the absent father of Meg, Jo, Amy and Beth of Little Women. Much more up my alley, I replaced Year of Wonder back on the shelf and walked around with March until, ultimately I found an altogether different book and placed March back on the shelf too (I ended up walking out with The Emporer's Children, which I have yet to read.)

Not forgetting about my interest for March, I used my old-faithful-tried-and-true method of attaining books and placed a hold for the book from the library.

I think I should have bought it. It's a great book. Clever, poignant, informative, inspiring, heartbreaking, interesting and historical, Brooks takes Louisa May Alcott's famous Little Women, and writes a parallel story about their father's experience during the same year. Little snippets are taken from Little Women, and it's as though you can see that famous play happening in the background in each scene. Sort of like Wicked and The Wizard of Oz, only more serious and important. After all, Peter March wasn't out flying on a broom, he was trying to serve the Union troops in the United States own Civil War.

Brooks bases Peter on Alcott's own father's journals, just as Alcott based her Little Women on herself and her sisters. Bronson Alcott, and his fictional representative, Peter March, are part of the intellectual elite who reside in Concord Massachusetts alongside their contemporaries, Walden, Thoreau, Hawthorn and Brown, who each make an appearance in the story. Idealistic abolutionists with Quaker leanings, March leaves his family to support the union's cause to end slavery and finds great conflict between his inner values and his outward actions.

Brooks writes exclusively in the first person and as a result, I, the reader, was able to understand Peter March as he was, as he wanted to be and as he failed to be. He is a fantastic character. My only complaint with the book is that she abandoned Peter for a few chapters and wrote as Marmee, his wife, when he lay sick with fever. She eventually returns to Peter's voice, which gives the story the resolution it needs, and while Marmees' thoughts are equally moving and necessary, it made the ending a little choppy.

Despite that lack of continuity, I enthusiastically recommend March. It will force you to examine your own viewpoints about war, education, race, marriage, courage, pride and love.

5 comments:

Lindsay said...

I hope you do end up reading Year of Wonders. I thought it was excellent. Until the end. Geraldine Brooks must have a problem with endings.

I'm off to go put March on hold at the library.

BAK said...

I loved this book. Not as much as I love Little Women, but it was really good.

If you ever read it, Year of Wonders is good, just painful. And, I know I always do this, but if you like the whole "bring an obscure character in a famous book out of oblivion" thing, Ahab's Wife by Sena Jeter Naslund is really, really good too.

Lori said...

Thanks for the review--I zoomed over to my library website to place a hold on a copy. I read Year of Wonders a number of years ago and really liked it.

Lucy, I love your book reviews! You stated my feelings exactly about On Chesil Beach and Housekeeping. Housekeeping especially feels to me like the emporer wearing no clothes. All that lush, gorgeous language describing...nuthin.

Amy Sorensen said...

I grew up reading Little Women...I'd re-read it two or three times a year. So I totally avoided March, because I didn't want it to ruin my memories of Little Women. Once I finally read it, though, I am so glad I did. Every once in awhile some of the images from it will pop into my head.

I DID find the Marmee voice a little bit...awkward, I guess. Actually, too short---like it made the book feel unbalanced. I wanted MORE Marmee.

Anyway---instead of Year of Wonders, you should try Doomsday Book (Connie Willis). Same topic (the Plague) but a different tone that makes it less painful.

Kristin said...

I can't wait to read this! I just put it on hold at the library. Thanks for the recommend.