Saturday, September 08, 2007

Book Review #16 - The God of Animals


Alice Winston is a 12 year-old girl whose dysfunctional and isolated family life has left her unable to cope when a classmate of her dies. Her father, Joe Winston, a horseman with too many of his own problems to worry about his daughter's, leaves her emotionally starved and physically overburdened. He doesn't notice as her clothes become too small and too tight and expects her to muck the horse stalls, take care of the horses and help out with her clinically depressed mother who hasn't left her bedroom in over a decade.

In this burdensome environment, her sixteen year-old sister elopes with a rodeo cowboy creating an even wider gulf between Alice and other girls her age. Sheila, a girl her age but from the other side of town, starts coming out for riding and showmanship lessons. The family financially depends on this girl and her money, forcing Alice to befriend Sheila although she has few of the necessary social skills to do so.

As the family business struggles financially, her father submits to what he calls his last resort and allows other people to board their pedigree horses in their barn. A group of rich women, dubbed the Catfish by Alice, start coming too frequently to socialize, ride their horse and drink out of paper cups and one of the women begins a dangerous flirtation with Alice's own emotionally starved father.

There are so many things I enjoyed about this book. The writing is beautiful and the author, Aryn Kyle, does an amazing job weaving in the landscape and weather to amplify the mood and the world of horse breeding and shows as the catalyst for Alice's coming of age. This would have been a much different story if told by her father, or her mother or even her older sister. But it was told through Alice and we understand her low self-worth, her confusion and desire to please, her ultimate need to know that she was being taken care of. I wanted to reach through the book and hug her and reassure her that she was doing a good job and that I noticed. All she wanted was to be noticed and accepted for who she was and what she was good at.

A haunting family story with a beautiful but harsh landscape, Alice grows up understanding that dreams don't always come true, the good guy doesn't always finish first and that nature can be cruel.

9 comments:

Melissa said...

Lucy, how do your choose your books? I'd love a list of your favorites. I haven't been having much luck with my method of random selection at the library.

melissamcconkie@gmail.com

Kelly said...

I've never heard of this book. Sounds so pleasingly painful.

Barb said...

You seem to have picked out a gooder - I'll add it to my booklist, and if I find it soon (I've never heard of this one - will it be in stock at my local bookstore)I'll read it next!

jenny said...

I too would be interested how you get your book lists. You seem to have such a variety. Looks like the next book I will be diving into is a book on Golden Retrievrs for Dummies. Stay tuned :)

Anonymous said...

Hmm...these books you read are only making my ever growing list longer. This one sounds very enticing, yet somber. One I will save for the winter maybe? I hope you make it on the 19th to the blogger bookclub- I am just loving the thought of discussing books with you.

Elizabeth said...

I love your reviews. I will be checking this one out for sure.

Amy said...

I love book reviews. I will put this one on my list. Thank you!

Lucy said...

My not-being-a-follower ideology gets thrown out the window when it comes to choosing books. I wish I could say that I labor through book stores and libraries finding little gems, but I'm horrible at finding a book on my own.

Mostly, I peruse other blogs, booklists on library websites, and amazon.com. This book was on a list of March's Notable Books of 2007 list on Amazon.com and I thought it sounded interesting. But this is also totally my kind of book. I love novels about life and family. I don't know why because so many seem so sad and dysfunctional and my own experience in life has been much, much more positive, but I find the writing and the glimpse into others' existences fascinating. Are there really families like this out there? Oh....I love and cherish my own.

FYI, I am much less squeamish about PG-13 when it comes to book. This particular book is really rather clean, but there are a few F-bombs. Like maybe five, but the author uses them honestly. I think.

Anonymous said...

Luc-

Just wondering if you are planning to come to the dinner with the Dinner Divas on Saturday night? Let either me or Jody know, okay!

Hope to see you there! :)